Pizza by the Sea

While some other NJ shore towns boast one iconic boardwalk pizza shop, Cape May offers a variety of traditional and wood-fired options for locals and visitors who want to enjoy an easy dinner option at the beach.

Below are the local restaurants offering a full menu that includes pizza for dine-in or take-out. To see a list of all the pizzerias on Cape Island, click here. 

Lucky Bones Back Water Grill

Lucky Bones features a Naples style brick-oven pizza with toppings ranging from pepperoni to local clams. Or if you’re in the mood for something a little thicker, order their Roman style sheet pizza. 

  • Address: 1200 NJ-109
  • Phone: 609-884-2663
  • Website

The Boiler Room

This underground pizzeria in the basement of Congress Hall serves up brick oven pizzas topped with ingredients sourced from Beach Plum Farm in West Cape May. Pair your choice with a farm-fresh salad (big enough to share) and an ice cold beer. 

  • Address: 200 Congress Place
  • Phone: 609-884-6507
  • Website

Panico's Bistro

Located inside an old church in West Cape May, this family-owned restaurant serves up classic style pizzas like Margherita, Bianco, and Pomodora. If you plan to dine there, be sure to bring along your favorite adult beverage as they are BYOB.

  • Address: 422 Broadway
  • Phone: 609-884-7170
  • Website
View All Cape May Pizza Places

Whichever pizza place you choose, consider ordering takeout and eating it on the beach. Nothing pairs quite as well as a pizza and a Cape May sunset!